But this is a matter of opinion albeit, an authoritative one, and not a statement of fact. Software freedom law center adds plone foundation as. Open source advocates slap verizon with gpl lawsuit. Armijn hemel is the worlds foremost expert on the technical aspects of gpl compliance. Nov 01, 2007 the software freedom law center has settled its first u. Jul 02, 2009 according to the interpretation of the software freedom law center the gpl might be viral after all. Apache 2 software can therefore be included in gplv3 projects, because the gplv3 license accepts our software into gplv3 works. Whitepaper by mark shuttleworth, ceo of canonical, ltd. This lawsuit uses what richard stallman calls tivoization as its defense. Software freedom law centercolumbia university school of law.
Software freedom law center goes after verizon over gpl cnet. The licenses were originally written by richard stallman, former head of the free software foundation fsf, for the gnu project, and grant the recipients of a computer program the rights of the free software. Software freedom law center adds plone foundation as newest. Software that detects gpl violations august 2007 forums. A practical guide to gpl compliance software freedom law.
Software freedom law center launches trademark war against. This is the largest lawsuit of its kind ever filed. I detailed analysis of the gnu gpl and related licenses. The free software foundation considers the apache license, version 2. There are sustained campaigns out there to undermine the gpl by a.
However, most of the good code is gpld, which requires releasing modifications and statically linked libraries back to the community under the. Jul 22, 2008 the software freedom law center, led by eben moglen, is a nonprofit organization set up to enforce the provisions of the gpl. We will bring together lawyers, developers, enterprise users, and other members of free and open source software foss communities to join us in exploring legal issues. Wider adoption of the gpl fits well with developing a more competitive software acquisition. The software freedom law center provides legal representation and other law related services to protect and advance free and open source. Eben moglen, fsf director and legal counsel, announced the creation of the software freedom law center sflc.
Lawsuit threatens to break new ground on the gpl and software. Aug 27, 2007 however, most of the good code is gpl d, which requires releasing modifications and statically linked libraries back to the community under the gpl. The linux kernel, cddl and related issues software. Sflc files bizarre legal action against its former client, software. Previously, he worked as inhouse counsel at ieee and as a staff attorney at the software freedom law center, where he advised community.
What they are saying is that any wordpress theme that is not gpl, is not compliant with the gpl license. Opensource and free software defenders allege that verizons fios wirelessrouter provider is not abiding by terms of the general public. There was a recent post on groklaw entitled fsfe and release guide to. Pingback from how the gpl works, or not gpouls out of memory blog on july 6, 2009 freedom law center, who was instrumental in creating the gpl version 3 license. The software freedom law center sflc is an organization that provides pro bono legal representation and related services to notforprofit developers of free softwareopen source software. Jul 06, 2009 software freedom law center says wordpress themes are gpl is a very misleading post title. Software freedom law center guide to gpl compliance 2nd. The software freedom law center sflc is an organization that provides pro bono legal representation and related services to notforprofit developers of free software open source software.
Software freedom law center wikimili, the free encyclopedia. Opensource and freesoftware defenders allege that verizons fios wirelessrouter. The software freedom law center sflc, provider of probono legal services to protect and advance freelibre and open source software foss, today published a guide to effective compliance with the gnu general public license gpl and related licenses. James vasile of the software freedom law center on gpl3, the. While the terms of the settlement were never disclosed, the software freedom law center and the software freedom conservancy, who assisted the busybox team. Also note that the gpl below is ed by the free software foundation, but the instance of code that it refers to the linux kernel is ed by me and others who actually wrote it. The software freedom law center, led by eben moglen, is a nonprofit organization set up to enforce the provisions of the gpl. The software freedom law center sflc has responded to a recent.
Free software foundation hopes to release final gpl v3 by. The software freedom law center sflc today announced that it has filed the first ever u. Introduction today, most companies are using open source software internally, and many are actively distributing open source. While version three of the gpl is now old news, there are still some points about it worth discussing, and many still have questions about what makes it different from previous versions of the widelyused gnu general public license. When versata software sued ameriprise financial services for breaching its software license, it unwittingly unearthed a gpl violation of its own and touched off another lawsuit that could prove to be a leading case on free and open source software licensing. The creation of the sflc will offer the fsf additional legal resources in its lgpl compliance efforts. Software freedom law center goes after verizon over gpl. It will also create a loose association whose members can consult with each other as necessary. Aaron williamson aaron williamson is an attorney at tor ekeland, p. Software freedom law center alleges that two companies distributing open source busybox are not providing access to the source code, as required by gpl by grant gross senior editor, idg news service. Software freedom law center guide to gpl compliance 2nd edition software freedom law center october 31, 2014. Nov 24, 2007 the software freedom law center sflc has filed what it describes as a second round of general public license gpl infringement lawsuits against companies that are allegedly using busybox without complying with the terms of the license.
Concerning a statement by the conservancy software freedom. Software freedom law center files first us gpl infringement suit the software freedom law center has filed a infringement suit on ryan paul sep 21, 2007 7. Software freedom law center says wordpress themes are gpl. The creation of the sflc will offer the fsf additional legal resources in its l gpl compliance efforts. If they dont sort things out on their own, then you should consider contacting the free software foundation or the software freedom law center, and maybe the authors of the packages too. Aug 21, 2008 the software freedom law center sflc, provider of probono legal services to protect and advance freelibre and open source software foss, today published a guide to effective compliance with the gnu general public license gpl and related licenses. The target of the suit, monsoon multimedia, on tuesday agreed to appoint an open source compliance officer to monitor its use of gpl code. The software freedom law center has settled its first u. The software freedom law center sflc took aim at 14 consumer electronics companies for violating gpl licensed products. Software freedom law center says wordpress themes are gpl is a very misleading post title. Software freedom law center opens free software foundation. However, law does differ from country to country, and commonly, software freedom licenses like the gpl must be considered under the law in the jurisdiction where any licensing dispute occurs.
Software freedom law center to represent the wine project. Software freedom law center publishes guide to gpl. Busybox is a lightweight set of standard unix utilities commonly. This whitepaper explains how a specific, existing form of foss software distribution, ubuntu core and snap technology, can achieve the goals of software governance.
On saturday, november 16th, the software freedom law center cohosted a hackathon with the freedombox foundation to commemorate the upcoming tenyear anniversary of the freedombox projects founding. The software freedom law center alleges that the telco has violated the terms of the open source general public license. Lawsuit threatens to break new ground on the gpl and. According to the interpretation of the software freedom law center the gpl might be viral after all. The software freedom law center refutes claims by embedded systems seller wasabi systems that companies using the gpl could be in violation of the sarbanesoxley act. Sep 21, 2007 software freedom law center files first us gpl infringement suit the software freedom law center has filed a infringement suit on ryan paul sep 21, 2007 7. The software freedom law center sflc has published a guide that explains the obligations imposed by gnus general public license gpl. The software freedom law center sflc yesterday filed a lawsuit in united states district court for the southern district of new york against verizon on behalf of open source software developer busybox. May 01, 2017 armijn hemel is the worlds foremost expert on the technical aspects of gpl compliance. Also note that the only valid version of the gpl as far as the kernel is concerned is this particular version of the license ie v2, not v2. Aug 22, 2008 the software freedom law center sflc has published a guide that explains the obligations imposed by gnus general public license gpl. James vasile of the software freedom law center discusses several legal topics of interest to users of free and open source software. This post takes a look at the legal issues raised by both cases and what they mean for foss producers and users.
Nov 30, 2005 available here boston and new york november 30, 2005 the free software foundation fsf and the software freedom law center sflc today released a document specifying the process and guidelines for revising the foundations gnu general public license gnu gpl. Software freedom law center publishes guide to gpl compliance. Software freedom law center guide to gpl compliance 2nd edition. The software freedom law center is an organization that provides pro bono legal representation and related. Multiple consumer electronics companies hit with gpl. Linux law group sues verizon over gpl violation zdnet. The software freedom law center sflc has filed what it describes as a second round of general public license gpl infringement lawsuits against companies that are allegedly using busybox without complying with the terms of the license. Professor eben moglen, president and executive director at software freedom law center.
James vasile of the software freedom law center on gpl3. How to read, understand, and comply with the provisions of the gnu gpl family of free software licenses. Org foundation hires software freedom law center x. At the hackathon, eben moglen delivered a speech in which he reflected on the past ten years of freedombox and the projects future. Software freedom law center files more busybox gpl.
Software freedom law center files gpl lawsuit in propria. In the filings, which target xterasys and highgain antennas, the sflc requests injunctions and asks that damages and. The software freedom law center is pleased to announce our 15th anniversary fall conference cohosted by columbia law school, which will take place on friday, november 1st, 2019. Free software foundation hopes to release final gpl v3 by jan. Speaking on a panel of attorneys involved in writing gpl v3, fontana, an attorney at the software freedom law center, said some of the wording in the current draft of gpl v3 is intentionally vague.
About a month ago, the software freedom law center sflc, the. Software freedom law center and conservancy liberal murmurs. The holders grant the freedom to copy, modify, convey, adapt, andor redistribute this work except appendices be under the terms of the creative commons attribution share alike 4. Aaron williamson, attorney for the sflc, said his organization had contacted extreme in february about its use of busybox, a set of lightweight unix utilities used in embedded systems and issued under the gpl. By joanne van erp montague page 1 davis wright tremaine llp october 2011 copyright issues with open source software i. In accordance with the software freedom law center s sflcs philosophy of assisting the community with gpl compliance cooperatively, this guide focuses on avoiding compliance actions and minimizing the negative impact when enforcement. This book is an indispensable starting point for all compliance engineers. Press release, software freedom law center, fsf and cisco. Software freedom law center guide to gpl compliance, 2nd edition, written by eben moglen and. Dec 07, 2007 software freedom law center goes after verizon over gpl. The software freedom law center has filed a lawsuit against 14 consumer electronics firms for allegedly violating the gnu general public license in the use of gpllicensed software in.
The creation of the sflc will offer the fsf additional legal resources in its lgpl compliance efforts fsf president richard stallman said, the fsf has been talking with eben moglen for some time, planning how we will work with the sflc. The software freedom law center provides practical advice for developers about including permissively licensed source. About the software freedom law center the software freedom law center chaired by eben moglen, one of the worlds leading experts on law as applied to software provides legal representation and other lawrelated services to protect and advance free and open source software. The organizations traditionally bringing complaints of copyleft noncompliance in historical order, the free software foundation, the software freedom law center, and the software freedom conservancy all fully investigate and verify complaints referred to them before making contact with apparently noncomplying parties. Feb 12, 2005 eben moglen, fsf director and legal counsel, announced the creation of the software freedom law center sflc. Software freedom law center files first us gpl infringement. Press release, software freedom law center, best buy, samsung, westinghouse, and eleven other brands. This is a guide to effective compliance with the gnu general public license gpl and related licenses.
It was launched in february 2005 with eben moglen as chairman. Fsf releases guidelines for revising the gpl free software. Software freedom law center local business facebook. How to read, understand, and comply with the provisions of the gnu gpl family of free. Org foundation software freedom law center adds plone foundation as newest client plone.
The foundation, based in houston, texas, supports the development and promotion of the open source content management system, plone, and its developer. Fsf president richard stallman said, the fsf has been talking with eben moglen for some time, planning how we will work with the sflc. Houston and new york, july, prnewswire the software freedom law center sflc, provider of probono legal services to protect and advance free and open source software foss, today announced it will represent the plone foundation. Monsoon settles gpl violation according to sd times, the software freedom law center sflc announced that it has reached a settlement with monsoon multimedia over its violation of the gpl. The licenses were originally written by richard stallman, former head of the free software foundation fsf, for the gnu project, and grant the recipients of a. The sflc, which has recently conducted a string of gpl. The gnu general public license gnu gpl or gpl is a series of widely used free software licenses that guarantee end users the freedom to run, study, share, and modify the software. Nov 08, 2017 software freedom law center and conservancy by neil mcgovern published november 8, 2017 updated november 8, 2017 before i start, i would like to make it clear that the below is entirely my personal view, and not necessarily that of the gnome foundation, the debian project, or anyone else. Software freedom law center and conservancy by neil mcgovern published november 8, 2017 updated november 8, 2017 before i start, i would like to make it clear that the below is entirely my personal view, and not necessarily that of the gnome foundation, the debian project, or anyone else.
145 1365 1568 967 1245 1130 725 172 1189 1076 1526 299 1169 1261 408 469 297 1357 1537 1131 1057 28 719 497 36 711 60 489 1362 187 1144